Georgia S and Toby's dating history revealed as they couple up on Love Island: All Stars

Toby said there's 'unfinished business'

Author: Charlotte RoszkoPublished 16th Jan 2024

It's safe to say that the highly-anticipated first series of Love Island: All Stars started with a bang, as we got to see some of the shows previous Islanders re-enter the iconic villa as they search for love once more.

The show certainly didn't hold back when it came to dramatic moments - reuniting exes Liberty Poole and Jake Cornish, and even bringing in Callum Jones and his ex-girlfriend Molly Smith as bombshells in what some fans have dubbed the 'greatest twist' in the show's history.

However, another pair with history is series seven Islander Toby Aromolaran and series four star Georgia Steel, who were coupled up together by the public vote. The pair mentioned that they had history - but what actually happened between them?

Have Toby and Georgia dated?

Despite starring on different series of Love Island, Toby and Georgia both competed on Love Island Games, which saw Islanders from the UK, Australian and American series compete in various challenges. The pair were coupled up for a brief period, before leaving the villa together on day nine of the show.

After their departure, Toby shared a picture of him and Georgia to his Instagram page, which he captioned: 'I can't lie I didn't see that coming... but the games are the games! Love all the support from you guys! So what's next then?'

Speaking about Georgia before the show, Toby said: "There might be unfinished business, to be fair. Like if she came in, I feel like we'll definitely have to speak about the Games and, obviously how we left together and like how we were going.

"But yeah, it's one of those ones where it'll be interesting to see if she does come in, it'll be interesting to see her and I think it will be interesting for her to see me as well."

Addressing her history with Toby on Monday's (15th January) show, Georgia explained: "Me and Toby have had a thing in the past, obviously nothing really progressed. However, me and Toby know each other really well, we're really comfortable with each other."

Take a look at the Love Island: All Stars cast:

Georgia Harrison: Series 3

Age: 29
From: Essex
Instagram: georgialouiseharrison

Toby Aromolaran: Series 7

Age: 24
From: Essex
Instagram: tobyaromolaran

Kaz Kamwi: Series 7

Age: 29
From: Essex
Instagram: kazkamwi

Chris Taylor: Series 5

Age: 33
From: Leicester
Instagram: christophertaylorofficial

Georgia Steel - Series 4

Age: 25
From: York
Instagram: geesteelx

Anton Danyluk: Series 5

Age: 29
From: Lanarkshire
Instagram: anton_danyluk

Hannah Elizabeth: Series 1

Age: 33
From: Liverpool
Instagram: hannahelizinsta

Jake Cornish: Series 7

Age: 26
From: Weston-super-Mare
Instagram: jakecornish7

Demi Jones: Series 6

Age: 25
From: Portsmouth
Instagram: demijones1

Luis Morrison: Series 1

Age: 29
From: London
Instagram: luismorrison39

Liberty Poole: Series 7

Age: 24
From: Birmingham
Instagram: libertypoolex

Mitch Taylor: Series 10

Age: 27
From: Sheffield
Instagram: mitcheltaylor_

Callum Jones: Series 6

Age: 27
From: Manchester
Instagram: _callum_jones

Molly Smith: Series 6

Age: 30
From: Manchester
Instagram: mollysmith19

Josh Ritchie: Series 1

Age: 29
From: Bolton
Instagram: joshuaritchie1

Arabella Chi: Series 5

Age: 32
From: London
Instagram: arabellachi

Tyler Cruickshank: Series 7

Age: 28
From: Croydon
Instagram: tylercruickshank_

Sophie Piper: Series 6

Age: 24
From: Essex
Instagram: sophpiper_

Tom Clare: Series 9

Age: 24
From: Barnsley
Instagram: tomclare

Joanna Chimonides: Series 5

Age: 27
From: London
Instagram: joannachimonides

Casey O'Gorman: Series 9

Age: 27
From: Hertfordshire
Instagram: caseyogorman

Joe Garratt: Series 5

Age: 27
From: London
Instagram: josephgarratt

Jess Gale: Series 6

Age: 24
From: Cambridge
Instagram: jessicarosegale

Eve Gale: Series 6

Age: 24
From: Cambridge
Instagram: evegale

Adam Maxted: Series 2

Age: 31
From: Belfast
Instagram: adammaxted

Love Island: All Stars airs every night at 9pm on ITV2/STV2.

Now read:

Fans dub Love Island bosses 'savage' for 'greatest twist in show's history'

Everything you need to know about Love Island host Maya Jama

Everything you need to know about Love Island: All Stars

How to listen to Tay FM:

For great music and incredible competitions tune into Tay FM on 96.4 and 102.8FM, online, on our Tay FM app, your DAB radio, or say ‘Play Tay FM’ on your Smart Speaker. We play you the biggest hits from the world’s hottest artists. You’ll find new favourites every day and hear the songs you've missed from the last few years.