EXCLUSIVE: Scottish Secretary warns against under-16 social media ban
Ian Murray says he's concerned about overregulation of social media for youngsters
Last updated 13th Dec 2024
The Scottish Secretary's warning against the overregulation of social media for youngsters after the First Minister indicated support for an Australian-style ban.
Earlier this week John Swinney said he thinks there's a "strong argument" for following in Australia in banning platforms like TikTok, Facebook and Instagram for under 16s.
Ian Murray’s responded, telling MFR News the UK Government will only support a ban if it's supported by the evidence.
In an exclusive interview with our Political Editor, Alan Smith, he said: "If the evidence points to that then, of course, the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport will look at it.
“But, on the other side of this, let's be hugely positive. Social media and technology for young people is hugely beneficial, and therefore we have to be careful we're not over-regulating to deny their access to what is a wonderful resource.
"Nothing's off the table but it has to be evidence based. So I'm quite so sure we'd go as far at this moment in time of banning under-16s from social media.
"My 4-and-a-half-year-old is involved in technology which I couldn't have even dreamt about when I was her age - it wasn't even on sci-fi shows! By the time she gets into twenties and going into her career, those jobs and that technology hasn't been invented yet.
“Of course it's a real concern, but we need to make sure policies are evidence-based, and they work."
Australian rules
Australia's rules are the strictest in the world - but will not take effect for another year.
Tech companies could be fined up to $50m ( £25.7m) if they don't comply with the legislation, which was passed to protect young people from the "harms" of social media.
But critics say questions remain about how the ban will work, as well as its impact on privacy and social connection.
'Social media storm' says Swinney
Speaking to us on Tuesday evening Mr Swinney said: "I've called for much stronger steps to be taken to regulate the activities of social media giants.
"I think young people are being caught up in a social media storm which can have a significant effect on their wellbeing.
"There are many benefits of social media, but there are also downsides.
"We've got to make sure children and young people are protected in this social media age.
"I think there's a strong argument for it and I know Australia's gone down that direction.