Scotland facing "whole new era of austerity" warns Finance Minister

Shona Robison is set to address MSPs after the summer recess

The First Minister is warning there are "tough decisions" ahead
Author: Molly TulettPublished 3rd Sep 2024

The Finance Secretary says Westminster is to blame for a “whole new era of austerity”, as MSPs return to Holyrood from the summer recess.

Shona Robison is set to update MSPs today on the scale of Scottish Government spending, with hundreds of millions of pounds cuts expected in a bid to plug a budget funding hole.

Some of the measures which have already been announced the redirection of money from a nature fund and a free iPad scheme to go towards local authority pay awards.

The independent Scottish Fiscal Commission has noted that more than half of the Government's resource spending is allocated to public sector pay and above-expectation increases in this area will lead to cuts elsewhere.

"Whole new era of austerity"

The First Minister has already warned there are more "tough decisions" ahead however, opposition parties say it is the SNP's own decisions which have led to the public finances being strained.

Ahead of her statement, Ms Robison said: "The SNP Government has delivered a balanced budget in every year that we have been in office - and we will continue to do so.

"I am proud to serve in a government which is investing hundreds of millions of pounds to lift children in Scotland out of poverty, and is ensuring our police, our nurses and our teachers are the best-paid in the UK.

"We have taken many tough choices - including asking those on higher incomes to pay a bit more income tax - in order that we can invest more in public services like our NHS.

"Tough decisions" ahead

"But the fact is, the Scottish Government operates with a largely fixed budget determined by Westminster and, under the Labour Government, it is clear that we are entering a whole new era of austerity.

"The cuts that they are proposing to make will have a profound effect on our ability to deliver for the people of Scotland - but (the) SNP Government will do everything we can to protect people and public services from the cuts that Westminster is making to our budget."

The Scottish Trade Unions Congress (STUC) believes the gap in funding could have been avoided.

General Secretary Roz Foyer said she would like to say, ‘I told you so’.

She added: “I would’ve liked to have seen the Scottish government actually listening to the STUC when they were setting their budgets and looking at £3.7bn of additional revenue that we showed them could be raised, if they chose to go down a path of taxing well.”

"I would hate to say 'I told you so'"

She stressed the need for ministers to take their share of responsibility, saying those at UK and Scottish level are to blame, calling on them to “seriously invest in public services”.

Ms Robison added: "Were Scotland an independent country, we would not be paying the price for bad decisions taken at Westminster - whether that be years of austerity cuts, Brexit, or reckless mini budgets - all of which have taken money out of the economy and funding for public services.

"Scotland should be able to determine our own future, and we should have full the powers to invest in our people, our public services and the planet as a way to building a more prosperous country."

With more than half a billion pounds worth of cuts potentially on the way, the Director of the Fraser of Allander Institute at Strathclyde University is warning it was “always the case” the Scottish Government was "budgeting too little for public sector pay”.

"Budgeting too little for public sector pay"

Mhairi Spowage said: “What might end up being affected quite a lot can be things like capital projects, but there’s a restriction on how much that can be used for day to day spending.

“More likely it’s going to be things that the government have gone to in the last couple of years when they’ve announced emergency budget measures in the middle of the year.

“Things like employability schemes and so on, where the money hasn’t yet been spent.”

Scottish Labour said there must be detailed explanations of the departmental budgets being cut.

Finance spokesman Michael Marra said: "With brutal cuts to services and potential job losses looming, the usual SNP secrecy and spin will not cut it.

"Brutal cuts to services"

"It's time for the SNP to come clean about the financial chaos it has created and tell us the truth about what lies ahead.

"The SNP has said essential jobs would be protected from cuts, but it has failed to say in any way what an essential job actually is.

"This incompetence and failure to plan is causing uncertainty for public sector workers and chaos for service leaders, who now need urgent clarity."

Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton said: "This SNP Government have gone four times over budget building ferries, sold off Scotland's prize seabed on the cheap and handed £50 million to an engineering firm that went bust.

"As a result, there is less money to go round for public services. They're promising to spend millions on misguided plans to give ministers more control over care services.

Need to "seriously invest in public services"

"The nationalists have got themselves in a mess because their focus has always been on breaking up the UK, not delivering public services."

A UK Government spokeswoman said: "We've been clear that tough decisions must be taken to restore economic stability and address the £22 billion hole in the public finances left by the last government. This is a challenge facing the whole of the UK, including Scotland.

"The Chancellor reiterated this in a constructive meeting with the First Minister and Finance Minister in Glasgow last week, and we are committed to working with the Scottish Government on our shared priorities to fix the foundations of our economy, so we can rebuild Britain and make every part of the United Kingdom better off."

Scottish Conservative finance spokesman Liz Smith said: "It is the SNP's financial mismanagement over their 17 years in power that has pushed public services beyond breaking point, yet the SNP leader acts like his party have done nothing wrong.

"They are solely responsible for record backlogs in our NHS, falling standards in our schools and councils having to cut day-to-day services year after year."

Hear all the latest news from across the North of Scotland on the hour, every hour, at MFR. Listen on FM, via our MFR app, on your DAB radio, online at MFR.co.uk, or say ‘Play MFR’ on your Smart Speaker.