Minister backs 'Suzanne's Law' to refuse parole for killers if victims not found

Murderers who will not reveal the location of their victim's body will be refused parole under justice law reforms

Author: Alice FaulknerPublished 19th Mar 2025

Murderers who fail to reveal the location of their victim's body will be refused parole, after the Scottish Government agreed to a Conservative MSP's proposal for "Suzanne's Law".

Named after Edinburgh bookkeeper Suzanne Pilley, who was murdered by her work colleague David Gilroy in 2010, Jamie Greene's proposal is set to be incorporated into an overhaul of the justice system.

Gilroy was given a life sentence for the murder of Ms Pilley, whose body has never been found.

She is thought to have been secretly buried in a remote part of Argyll.

'Deep hurt'

On Wednesday, Holyrood's Criminal Justice Committee debated amendments to the Victims, Witnesses, and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill at stage two.

Justice Secretary Angela Constance acknowledged the "deep hurt" caused to families and friends when a loved one's remains cannot be found.

She backed Mr Greene's amendment, saying: "I am happy to support this amendment, it may be that we propose some tweaks to the drafting at stage three... some minor changes may be needed but I'm happy to support amendment 260 for now."

'First step'

Mr Greene said later: "This is a fantastic victory for victims and their families, and I'm delighted SNP ministers have agreed to back Suzanne's Law, which I first brought forward in my own Victims Law proposals.

"It should always be the case that killers like David Gilroy should not be released until they disclose the whereabouts of a victim's remains.

"The callous refusal of dangerous criminals to reveal such information only causes more suffering for families, which is why it is welcome the SNP have agreed with my call for the parole board to always take this into account in these cases.

"This, alongside my many other amendments to their justice reform Bill, should represent the first step in the SNP finally prioritising the needs of victims in Scotland's justice criminal system after repeatedly treating them as an afterthought."

You can hear the latest news on Kerrang! Radio.

Rayo PremiumRayo Premium

Non-Stop Kerrang! Radio

Kerrang! Radio