Teesside victim of SIM card scam calls for tougher security on mobiles
Ian Finlay noticed unusual activity when he was abroad
A Teesside man, who fell victim to a SIM swap scam, is calling for tougher security on mobile phones after losing £50,000.
Ian Finlay, from Maltby near Ingleby Barwick, is wanting companies to better protect customers.
He and his wife were on holiday in Australia earlier this year when he noticed unusual activity on his credit card and bank accounts while using banking apps on his own mobile.
A total of five credit card accounts and three bank accounts were compromised with more than £50k taken fraudulently.
The banks had been suspicious of the activity and worked with Ian to make sure he was not out of pocket. He got the money back eventually.
However, he was told he had likely been the victim of identity theft following a SIM card swap scam.
Ian said: "It’s difficult to describe how upsetting it is to be on the other side of the world, on a ship in the middle of the ocean and have all your cards go down
“My wife and I felt totally helpless; it was quite scary, and our first thought was ‘what have we done wrong?’ We started going over our tracks, wondering where we could have made a mistake, but we hadn’t. We started to feel very angry.”
The scam happened when a duplicate SIM was sent, by request from a fraudster to an address in London. The offender then had access to Ian’s mobile phone account, his online banking apps – and, therefore, his accounts and money.
On returning to the UK, Ian worked with his mobile phone provider to review and resolve the problem.
During this time, the fraudster managed to access Ian’s mobile account again, upgraded the account and added additional handsets.
Unhappy with the response from the phone company, Ian took his case to the Communications Ombudsman.
The Ombudsman upheld his complaint, confirming it had found ‘shortfalls’ in the mobile provider’s service. Ian was awarded £200 as a goodwill gesture, which he refused on the basis he feels the issue has not been taken seriously enough.
Since the incident, Ian has been working with the PCC-funded Victim Care and Advice Service (VCAS), which supports victims of crime in Cleveland.
He is campaigning to raise awareness of the issue and to get mobile ‘phone companies to tighten up security and processes around customer data.
Ian said: “Mobile phone companies need to provide a much higher level duty of care than they currently recognise. They should be regulated in the same way as the banking sector, to improve accountability.
“Accessing someone’s mobile phone data can have significant consequences; fraudsters can access multiple bank accounts and credit cards through one phone.”
Ian has attended a VCAS fraud support session to raise awareness and help others. He has also talked at length with North East Regional Organised Crime Unit (NEROCU) and Regional Economic and Cyber Crime (RECCC) officers.
Dave Mead, manager of VCAS, said SIM swap scams and fraud of this kind can have a huge impact on victims.
He sad: “Everyone reacts differently, but it’s common to feel targeted as it can feel very personal, which leads people to feel less trusting.
“Anger, anxiety, feelings of helplessness are very normal and we are here support you and help you recover.”
Matt Storey, Cleveland's Police and Crime Commissioner, said: “Ian’s tenacity paid off and he did manage to claw back his cash.
“Less pro-active individuals would have found the process of dealing with the banks, mobile ‘phone provider and Ombudsman too daunting and may have given up.
“Well done to Ian for fighting his corner and winning his case with the Ombudsman!
“However, the result has been to highlight just how easy it is to “steal” someone’s identity and gain access to their personal accounts.
“It demonstrates the need for tighter security on any account, where customers could stand to lose a substantial amount of money if it is compromised.”
Anyone who has been a victim of crime, including fraud, can get free, confidential support from VCAS.