Sheffield man sentenced for stabbing parents to death in Totley

James Andrews pleaded guilty to manslaughter by diminished responsibility

Author: Rosanna Robins Published 28th Jul 2023

A man has been has been detained indefinitely in a secure mental health hospital for killing his parents at their home in Sheffield.

James Andrews, 52, who is known to his family as Duncan, previously pleaded guilty to the manslaughter of Mary and Bryan Andrews by reason of diminished responsibility.

The couple, who were aged 76 and 79, were stabbed to death at their home on Terrey Road in Totley on 27th November 2022.

Officers found Andrews, of Reney Avenue, Greenhill, standing at the top of the stairs armed with a knife and covered in blood.

They attempted to negotiate with him before eventually using Taser and arresting him.

A hearing at Sheffield Crown Court previously heard that the defendant was being held at a high security hospital.

The court heard how Mrs Andrews suffered 82 stabs wounds and her husband also had multiple injuries.

A judge was told that Andrews said to officers who arrested him using a Taser to restrain him: "I just killed my mum and dad."

David Brooke KC, prosecuting, told the court that Andrews later said he had been hearing voices for months and that "God had made him do what he had done".

Sally Andrews read a victim personal statement to the court, saying: "We weren't made victims on November 27, we have been victims of a broken health and social service for at least two years, if not more.

"Medical letters my brother received outline some of the failures, stating he 'fell in between services', that he 'remained on waiting lists'.

"Then there was the poor liaison with him, no regard for the family that were encouraged to support him and no return of calls.

"We believe this very much contributed to the outcome on that fateful day."

Ms Andrews said: "Where were the mental health team or epilepsy liaison team?"

And she added: "In the absence of these professionals our family paid the ultimate price.

"My parents sacrificed their lives so he could get a diagnosis of a 'serious mental illness' - something we had been trying to get them to acknowledge for some time."

Ms Andrews said "On the day our parents died we also lost our brother following an act that, we were told, he was unlikely to be in control of.

"An act that broke the trust we had in him and has rocked the foundations of the life I and many others have shared with him."

Both sisters told the court they were very concerned for the safety of their children if their brother was ever released.

The judge, Mrs Justice Stacey, told Andrews he will be detained at Rampton Special Hospital "without limit of time" after he admitted manslaughter by reason of diminished responsibility at a previous hearing.

Hear all the latest news from across the UK on the hour, every hour, on Greatest Hits Radio on DAB, smartspeaker, at greatesthitsradio.co.uk, and on the Rayo app.