Woman guilty of murdering Kasey Anderson in Croxteth

Anderson desperately tried to call for help after being stabbed in the heart

Author: Nathan Marsh & Lynda RoughleyPublished 4th Oct 2023

A woman has been found guilty of the murder of Kasey Anderson following an incident of domestic violence in Croxteth earlier this year.

Natalie Bennett, 47, of Carr Lane East, was found guilty by a jury today, Wednesday 4 October, at Liverpool Crown Court.

Kasey, aged 24, from Croxteth, was stabbed at around 6.30pm on Carr Lane East on Saturday 12 March.

Despite being taken to hospital with injuries to his chest and leg, Kasey sadly passed away in hospital on Friday 31 March.

Following an investigation, detectives were able to prove that Bennett used a knife to stab her boyfriend Kasey following a domestic incident.

Natalie Bennett

A Liverpool Crown Court jury took four hours 42 minutes to unanimously convict Natalie Bennett following a seven day long trial.

The 47-year-old showed no emotion but supporters of victim Kasey Anderson shouted “yes” and began clapping with many in floods of tears.

Sentence on Bennett, of Carr Lane East, Croxteth, was postponed until November 10 to enable a psychiatric report to be prepared.

Her KC Stan Reiz said that a psychological report suggested “there were signs that she may suffer from mental disorder - post traumatic stress disorder and potentially bi-polar.”

He said it was recommended that she be assessed by a psychiatrist and asked that that should be allowed as it might provide some mitigation.

Judge Denis Watson, KC, told Bennett, who had claimed self-defence, “There can only be one sentence which is imprisonment for life.

“There can only be one sentence which is imprisonment for life.

“However Mr Reiz tells me it is just possible there may be some medical information from a psychiatrist which will touch on the minimum term that I will consider before release.”

Before being taken to the cells Bennett looked over towards where her dad was sitting.

During the trial the jury heard that she called the dying victim “a little rat” as he lay in the street outside her home desperately calling 999 having been slashed several times with a knife and stabbed twice on March 11. He died a week before his 25th birthday on March 31 this year.

Bennett, who was captured on ring bell footage from next door trying to stab him in the head, was arrested and claimed to the police that he had arrived injured at her home "like that".

He was found to have sustained a deep stab wound to his chest, which damaged his left lung and heart. He also had superficial slash wounds to his neck, right shoulder, lower back and left forearm, as well as a "shallow" stab wound to his right lower leg.

Detective Inspector Ben Wayment said:

“This was a vicious and calculated attack by Bennett that sadly resulted in the death of a young man.

“Our thoughts remain with Kasey’s family at this time and we hope this conviction brings them some comfort.”

Bennett will be sentenced on Friday 10 November.

If you have any non-urgent information on domestic abuse – if you are a victim or believe someone you know is a victim - you can contact direct message @MerPolCC on Twitter, ‘Merseyside Police Contact Centre’ on Facebook or contact @CrimestoppersUK, anonymously on 0800 555 111.

If you are in immediate danger, always call 999. If you ring 999 and are not in a safe position to speak to us then cough, or tap, the phone and press 55, when prompted. This will alert the operator that you need assistance and we will provide support.

Online – You can report online domestic abuse to us online Report domestic abuse | Merseyside Police and someone will get back to you, via your specified method, within 24 hours.

If you’re affected by issues raised in this article, there is further help available:

Paul Lavelle Foundation – info@paullavellefoundation.co.uk 0151 651 3777 – Support Line

Refuge (includes information for men) | refuge.org.uk | 0808 200 0247 (24 hours)

National Domestic Violence helpline on 0808 200 0247(24 hours)

Women’s Aid | womensaid.org.uk | 0808 200 0247 (24 hours) I need help - information and support on domestic abuse (womensaid.org.uk)

Hear all the latest news from across the UK on the hour, every hour, on Greatest Hits Radio on DAB, at greatesthitsradio.co.uk, and on the Greatest Hits Radio app.