The decision to end the Lincoln Christmas Market is being disputed
Following the decision to end the Christmas Market, the Conservative Group have decided to formally 'call in' the decision by the City of Lincoln Council
Last updated 21st Feb 2023
Lincoln MP Karl McCartney accused the City Council of “acting like a convention of Grinches or Scrooges” after they agreed to scrap Lincoln Christmas market in its current form on Monday night.
The authority’s executive committee voted in favour of reallocating the £260,000 budget for the Christmas market into a wider events programme throughout the year, including a new “Christmas in Lincoln” offer.
Councillors agreed with officers that the event had become too big (320,000 visitors over four days in 2022) and faced becoming “unsafe” telling the public present that they had explored all options.
However, Mr McCartney said following the meeting:
“The Labour councillors have acted a bit like a convention of Grinches or Scrooges this evening.
“I don’t think 30 minutes, if that, of discussion before they voted unanimously to scrap a 40-year-old Christmas market is giving due consideration and justice to the decision that they’ve made.”
He pointed to the near 4,000 signature petition to save the market organised by Lincoln business owner Rachel Whitaker.
“Yes, there are people who have an issue with the market, but the vast majority knows it puts Lincoln on the map,” the Lincoln MP said.
“Ultimately not only is it financially viable, it is also a very good window and advert and marketing for the city of Lincoln and the gateway for the rest of Lincolnshire.
“Yes, there are safety concerns and of course, nobody wants anybody to be put in any harm’s way at all. But that’s all manageable.”
The Conservative group on the City Council has already confirmed it will be calling-in the decision “due to the lack of public consultation and the way in which the decision has been made”.
Conservative Group leader Councillor Tom Dyer said: “My real concern is the lack of consultation with businesses and residents, and I’m keen to challenge some of the comments made by the officers this evening in respect of the cost implications.
“There are many things that make Lincoln a special place for people to visit, but the Lincoln Christmas Market is one of the key events in the year and I’ve got real concerns that this six week event programme won’t be anywhere near as popular,” he said.
It means the proposals will go to the scrutiny committee, who will be able to ask questions and make further recommendations for the executive to consider.
Campaigner Rachel Whitaker, who was sat in the public gallery, said she felt “incredibly frustrated and bemused” by the decision.
She believes there were still more questions to be answered, including needing concrete figures on the impact of the decision.
“They just need to evolve it like loads of other cities who have done the same. They’ve made it work.
“It’s a hugely popular event which delivers massive amounts of money back to the immediate and wider economy.
“The decision is really disappointing and short sighted.”
Responding to some of the criticisms, council leader Ric Metcalfe again reiterated regret that the public hadn’t been involved with internal discussions around the market.
He said opinion on the market was “extremely divided” but that the authority had a responsibility to public safety rather than a popular vote.
Asked if he was confident the council could replace the popularity of the existing market, Councillor Metcalfe said that although it was of “intrinsic importance” there were also “a lot of fantastic assets in the city”.
“Hundreds of thousands come to visit the Cathedral, the castle, the tens of thousands we draw on Lincoln’s shopping offer.
“We’ve got some great strengths we can play to, even without our traditional Christmas market, and I think we have to be as creative as we possibly can be… to come up with something that will be as beneficial in terms of visitor numbers and commercial value of attracting people to Lincoln.
“I’m confident we can do that,” Councillor Metcalfe said.