Inquest rules death of woman hit by Obby Oss costume in Padstow was accidental
The coroner is writing to the Government with his concerns about the management of large events
Last updated 7th Apr 2022
A coroner has ruled that the death of a woman who was hit by an Obby Oss costume in Padstow was accidental.
Laura Smallwood was hit in the neck by the costume – a large wooden circle weighing more than 50lb worn by a masked male dancer - on May Day in 2019
The 34-year-old paediatric nurse died in hospital on May 4 2019 – three days after the centuries-old Obby Oss festival, attended by up to 20,000 people each year.
The senior coroner for Cornwall is going to write to the Government with his concerns about the management of large events following Laura's death.
Andrew Cox said the two Osses posed a risk to the public.
“The packed nature of the streets, the fact people have inevitably been drinking alcohol and will not be paying full attention to what is happening around them, means the risk of inadvertent, unintended contact between the Oss and a member of the public is obvious,” he said.
The inquest in Truro heard that two Osses parade through the town and each has a separate organising committee.
Mr Cox said contact between the committees and other agencies up to 2018 was “limited and far from ideal”.
“I have heard that up to 20,000 people attend the event and it cannot be right, in my view, to have an event of that size with, for example, no arrangements in place for reuniting lost children with their parents or a community first responder being able to gain access to an emergency because of a padlocked gate,” he said.
“It is only fair to note that it was a situation that had begun to improve even before these events, and it is reassuring to hear there has been a recognition of the need to move with the times and to do more.
“I find it frankly surprising for an event of this size there is still no single event organiser who is involved with the local safety advisory group, the police and other external agencies.
“Sensible planning and risk reduction is inevitably compromised as a consequence.
“I have no wish to be Job’s comforter or to be the manifestation of a nanny state.
“I want May Day to continue, and I want it to flourish, yet my professional colleagues have been called on to deal with disasters regularly over the past few years.
“You only have to think of Manchester Arena, Grenfell Tower, London Bridge or the Shoreham plane crash.
“Terrible things happen to innocent people at the most unexpected of times and I would be failing in my duties were I not to raise my concerns here.”
The coroner said his preventing future deaths report would highlight to the Government his concerns about events not being compelled to have an organiser and also the police’s lack of powers to stop them.
The inquest heard Mrs Smallwood, from Padstow, collapsed after being struck by the Oss.
A post-mortem examination found she had suffered an earlier head injury around 10 days before she died and had also been involved in a minor scuffle with a woman at the parade.
Mr Cox said Mrs Smallwood had not complained of the earlier injury and “laughed off” the confrontation.
“I find that Laura had not recovered fully from the effects of this injury and so she was at increased vulnerability or susceptibility to further injury,” he said.
“I do not believe, however, that Laura’s collapse on May 1 was attributable to a delayed natural progression of the injury sustained 10 days before her death.
“In other words, I consider it far more likely that something else has intervened.”
Mr Cox said witnesses saw the Oss dancer stumble and the costume hit Mrs Smallwood’s neck.
“I consider the proximity in time between this incident and Laura’s acute deterioration to be far more than coincidental,” he said.
“On the evidence I find as fact that the Oss struck Laura and it is far more likely than not that this caused the injuries identified at post-mortem that led directly to her death.”
He recorded a conclusion of accidental death.