Derek Mackay to face MSPs on his role in CalMac ferry scandal

The former finance minister is returning to Holyrood

Author: Rob WallerPublished 8th Sep 2022
Last updated 8th Sep 2022

There's going to be a rare public appearance from former finance secretary Derek Mackay who is going to Holyrood to give evidence on the scandal surrounding the delayed construction of two ferries for CalMac at the Ferguson Marine yard in Port Glasgow.

Mr Mackay was the minister who approved the £97 million contract for vessels with then privately-owed yard before later responsible for bringing it into public ownership to save it from administration.

The vessels are around five years late and will cost more that twice their budget, with mounting disquiet in island communities, including Arran, which had suffered from repeated breakdowns and an unreliable ferry service from the ageing CalMac fleet.

Ferguson warning from officials

The Scottish Government's ferry procurement body Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited (CMAL) warned against giving the contract to Ferguson before the decision was made and it is not clear why the decision was taken to disregard the body's evidence.

A recent report found that the ferries, the Glen Sannox and as-yet-unnamed 802, would cost at least two-and-a-half times more than initially planned, with the Scottish Government confirming this week they will not be delivered until May and December of next year, respectively.

The report also found there was an insufficient paper trail documenting why the decision was made to give the contract to the Port Glasgow yard despite the objections of CMAL.

Private messages scandal

The former finance secretary stepped down after more than 100 inappropriate messages he sent to a 16-year-old boy were made public by the Scottish Sun.

Mr Mackay was not publicly spotted in Holyrood after the scandal, and stood down at last year's election.

But the former Renfrewshire North MSP will return to the Scottish Parliament on Thursday as he appears before the Public Audit Committee as part of its inquiry into the delays and overspends at Ferguson Marine.

MSPs demand answers

Scottish Lib Dem MSP Willie Rennie said taxpayers deserve "fulsome answers" on the issue.

"The First Minister and her ministers sought to pin the blame for the catastrophe at Ferguson's on Derek Mackay so this will be an opportunity for him to set the record straight," Mr Rennie said.

"I am sure he will want to be clear about who was responsible and why.

"Every SNP minister, past and present, has been avoiding the question of why warnings about the ferry deal were ignored.

"Islanders and the shipyard workers as well as the taxpayer deserve fulsome answers from someone who was in the room when the decisions were taken. These mistakes have cost five years and £250 million."

Hear all the latest news from across Edinburgh, the Lothians, Fife and Falkirk on Forth 1. Listen on FM, via the Rayo app, on DAB or on your smart speaker.