Michael Beale questions SFA appeal process after Graeme Shinnie ban

The Aberdeen midfielder was given an extra one game suspension following a failed appeal

Published 21st Apr 2023
Last updated 21st Apr 2023

Michael Beale has questioned the Scottish Football Association's appeals process after Aberdeen's Graeme Shinnie was controversially handed an extra game ban for appealing a red card.

The Dons captain was sent off late in last Friday's victory over Ross County in Dingwall following a strong challenge on defender Jack Baldwin, the decision coming following a VAR intervention.

Shinnie, on loan from Wigan, faced an automatic two-match ban and an extra one-game suspension because he had been sent off for the first time in his career in his previous game against St Johnstone.

However, the 31-year-old midfielder emerged from the SFA appeals process with a four-game ban after the independent panel decided the club had either been "frivolous" with their appeal or submitted it with no likelihood of winning.

PFA Scotland called for changes to the process and ahead of the trip to Pittodrie on Sunday, where Rangers will have the benefit of Shinnie's absence in the final cinch Premiership fixture before the split, Beale gave his thoughts on the issue.

"I have not seen the challenge but what I would say is I don't like this idea that if you ask a question then you get more," said the Gers manager, who revealed midfielder Ryan Jack will be out for "three or four weeks" with an unspecified injury and thus miss next week's Scottish Cup semi-final against Celtic at Hampden Park.

"The ban is the ban.

"I don't think you should be penalised more for asking the question. That seems a little bit harsh to me.

"I wouldn't want that for one of my players.

"Graeme is a committed player. He plays in the middle of midfield and has to make tackles and go for challenges.

"As I say, I haven't seen it, but either way, if you appeal, you are asking a question, and you shouldn't get penalised more.

"It is like we don't want people to appeal. We have to look at that."

The Light Blues are 12 points behind champions-elect Celtic and with little chance of winning the title, the semi-final against Ange Postecoglou's side takes on added importance as Rangers look to retain the trophy while preventing their Old Firm rivals from having the chance of capturing a domestic treble.

Injury News

Scott Wright returns to the squad for the Aberdeen game but Ridvan Yilmaz, Antonio Colak and Connor Goldson remain out with the latter two set to return against Celtic.

Midfielder Alex Lowry has also been added to the injured list while Kemar Roofe (hip), Tom Lawrence (heel), Steven Davis (knee) and Filip Helander (foot) have been out long term.

Beale said: "We will play the strongest team that is available this weekend for this game.

"There are seven/eight days between games. In general we have momentum and I want to continue with that."

Beale has been away recently meeting potential new signings face-to-face and revealed he is closing in on their first summer signings.

He said: "There are one or two things we are not far away from sealing. So I am really happy."

Asked about Burnley's reported interest in Kent, who is out of contract at the end of the season, the former QPR boss said: "I don't know anything about that. There will be a lot of rumours because he is out of contract and is a good player."

Hear the latest news on Clyde 1 on FM, DAB, smart speaker or the Rayo app.

Rangers Top Scorers

Ally McCoist

Ally McCoist scored 355 goals in his 581 appearances for Rangers between 1983-1998.

Bob McPhail

Bob McPhail scored 261 goals in all competitions for Rangers between 1927-1940.

Jimmy Smith

Jimmy Smith scored 249 goals in between 1930-1946.

Jimmy Fleming

Fleming scored 220 goals between 1925-1934.

Derek Johnstone

Derek Johnstone scored 210 goals for Rangers in his 549 appearances for the club. He played from 1970-1983, then again in the 1985/86 season.

Ralph Brand

Brand scored 206 goals in all competitions from 1954-1965.

Willie Reid

He scored 195 goals between 1909-1920.

Willie Thornton

Thornton scored 194 goals for Rangers between 1936-1954.

Robert C. Hamilton

Hamilton scored 184 goals in his 164 appearances. He played from 1897-1908.

Andy Cunningham

He scored 182 goals in his 350 appearances. Cunningham played from 1915-1928.