Ange Postecoglou frustrated at implementation of VAR

The Celtic boss is unhappy at how the technology is being used in Scotland

Published 5th Nov 2022

Celtic manager Ange Postecoglou expressed major frustration with the implementation of VAR following a dramatic 4-2 win over Dundee United as he claimed technology was changing the game and disrupting entertainment.

United scored their first of two equalisers from a VAR-assisted penalty and the Australian was baffled over how long it took to look at other incidents including Sead Haksabanovic's second goal and Liel Abada's stoppage-time effort, which was checked for offside.

"I don't think people fell in love with football just to be sitting around waiting for someone in a building miles away to decide outcomes," Postecoglou said.

"They do not need to take that long. If they have seven camera angles it seems like they want to look at every one. I know it's early doors and it's a new toy that everyone wants to use but you can't be disrupting games like this."

Steven Fletcher cancelled out Haksabanovic's early tap-in from the spot after Alexandro Bernabei was booked for handball, after referee David Dickinson reviewed footage of the United striker's header hitting him on the arm after he jumped for a header.

"It seems like any time the ball touches your hand in the box - apart from when you are playing Hearts away - it's a penalty," Postecoglou said.

"So if that's the case, they could have seen that in the first screen that it hit Berna's arm. But why take so long?

"His arm is in, I think, a natural position when you go up for a header. He is not even looking at it and it's a yellow card. It's the reason I took him off at half-time, I had no faith that I could keep him on because anything could come across.

"This is not me having a rant about VAR. I have no issue with VAR, I just have an issue with how it's being used. It's changing our game. It's changing what we all knew to be the laws of the game.

"I was always pretty clear what a handball was, deliberate handball. I played the game, you kind of know. But it seems that's not the way.

"That's the problem we have got now, we have let technology come into the game and rules that have been in place for over a century that we are all comfortable with are all of a sudden having to be looked at.

"I don't think that's what VAR was for. VAR, I thought, was there to pick up clear and obvious errors. Clear and obvious. Someone is having a shot from that distance and it hits his arm, how they can say that's clear and obvious? I don't get it.

"The problem with technology is they are going to have to change a lot of rules because they are re-refereeing the game, which is the one thing they said they wouldn't do. But they are, there's no doubt about it.

"And I feel for the officials because I have no doubt that they are scared to make decisions, they would much rather let it go and see if VAR picks something up.

"We scored the second goal and we were celebrating for two minutes and they are still checking when they are about to kick-off. What the hell were we waiting for? There was nothing there, I could see that in the first screen."

Postecoglou was also frustrated over video referee Nick Walsh's lengthy check for a possible red card against Craig Sibbald for a high boot when Dickinson had not even given a foul.

He added: "I'll cop teething problems but we have got to be learning along the way. I mean five minutes added on to the first half of a game of football. It is crazy.

"We can't take away from the fact that we have 60,000 people here. Of course they want to see us win but they are also coming to watch a spectacle.

"They are not coming to watch someone in a building miles away take two or three minutes to make a decision. I just don't think that's what it's for. Anyway, that's my rant."

United levelled for a second time in the 87th minute when Dylan Levitt's cross appeared to go straight in after Tony Watt tried to glance home.

But Kyogo Furuhashi headed home from a last-minute corner before Abada made sure of a win that sent Celtic seven points clear in the cinch Premiership.

United head coach Liam Fox said: "I'm more frustrated for the players than anything else, they put so much into the game.

"We all know how difficult it is to take anything from Celtic Park, so to get ourselves in a position to do that and then to switch off from a set-piece.

"It's not good enough from us that late in the game. We know there's going to be an onslaught.

"We worked on that during the week, which makes it even more frustrating. I understand when you make subs that there's an element of change to the set-ups that we do but we need people to take responsibility and step up in these moments."

Founded in 1888, Willie Maley was Celtic's first manager and one of the most successful managers in Scottish football history. He managed the club from 1897 to 1940, winning thirty major trophies (16 league championships and 14 Scottish Cups).

Jimmy McStay (circled) managed Celtic between 1940 and 1945. However, this clashed with the suspension of the League and Scottish Cup during wartime, meaning he never had the opportunity to manage the club in official competitions.

All-time leading goalscorer in top-flight British football Jimmy McGrory managed Celtic from 1945 to 1965. He won one First Division trophy, two Scottish League Cups, two Scottish Cups, four Glasgow Cups, one Coronation Cup, one Saint Mungo Cup and four Glasgow Charity Cups.

Jock Stein managed Celtic from 1965 to 1978 and guided Celtic to nine successive Scottish League championships between 1966 and 1974. He also won one European Cup, eight Scottish Cups, six Scottish League Cups, five Glasgow Cups and one Drybrough Cup.

Billy McNeil managed Celtic from 1978 to 1983. McNeil won three Scottish League titles, one Scottish Cup, one Scottish League Cup and one Glasgow Cup.
McNeil returned from 1987 to 1991 where he won one Scottish League title and two Scottish Cups.

David Hay managed Celtic from 1983 to 1987 and won one Scottish League title and one Scottish Cup.

Liam Brady managed Celtic from 1991 to 1993 but failed to win any trophies.

Lou Macari managed Celtic from 1993 to 1994 but he failed to win any trophies.

Tommy Burns managed Celtic from 1994 to 1997 and he won one Scottish Cup.

Wim Jansen managed Celtic from 1997 to 1998 and won One Scottish Premier Division Title and One Scottish League Cup.

Jozef Venglos managed Celtic from 1998 to 1999 but did not win any trophies

John Barnes managed Celtic from 1999 to 2000 but did not win any trophies.

Kenny Dalglish managed Celtic in 2000 and won one Scottish League Cup

Martin O'Neil managed Celtic from 2000 to 20005 and won three Scottish Premier Leagues, three Scottish Cups and one Scottish League Cup.

Gordon Strachan managed Celtic from 2005 to 2009 and won three consecutive Scottish Premier League Titles, one Scottish Cup and two Scottish League Cups.

Tony Mowbray managed Celtic from 2009 to 2010 but failed to win any trophies.

Neil Lennon managed Celtic from 2010 to 2014 and he won three Scottish Premier League titles and two Scottish Cups.
Lennon returned from 2019 to 2021, where he won two more League titles, two Scottish Cups and one Scottish League Cup.

Ronny Delia managed from 2014 to 2016 where he won two Scottish Premierships and one Scottish League Cup.

Brendan Rodgers managed Celtic from 2016 to 2019 where he won two Scottish Premierships, two Scottish Cups and three Scottish League Cups.

Ange Postecoglou took over as Celtic manager in 2021 and has won a Scottish League Cup.